Comparez l'assurance auto au Québec Compare auto insurance in Québec Gratuit · Sans engagementFree · No obligation

Guide · Updated November 15, 2026 · 8 min read

Parking lot accident in Québec, who is responsible

Disclosure: this article is published by SoumissionAuto.ca, an independent information site. If you request a quote through our links, we may receive compensation from licensed partners, at no cost to you. Learn more.

A man of Haitian descent in his early forties stands in an outdoor parking lot on an autumn afternoon, phone in hand, looking calm

A parking lot accident in Québec is not automatically split down the middle. To establish who is responsible, your insurer applies the fault chart of the Direct Compensation Agreement, which has a case for parking lots with no traffic signs and others for backing up, parked vehicles and opening a door. Contrary to popular belief, the Groupement des assureurs automobiles (GAA) points out, liability for an accident in a parking lot is not always shared 50% by each driver.

The Agreement applies to collisions in Québec between two or more vehicles whose owners have been identified (Article 3): each driver deals with their own insurer, which compensates them according to their share of fault. At the scene, the obligations of the Highway Safety Code apply just as they do on the street.

A few typical situations, as the chart settles them:

Situation Share under the chart What to do at the scene
One vehicle backs up, the other does not 100% for the one backing up (case 11) Joint report and photos
Both vehicles back up 50% each (case 11) Joint report and photos
Leaving a space into the alley 100% for the one leaving (case 15) Photograph the space and the alley
Leaving a side alley 100% for the one leaving it (case 15) Photograph both alleys
Parked vehicle hit 0% for the parked vehicle (case 3c) Reach the owner, or the police
Door opened 100% for whoever opens it (case 12) Note who opened the door

Your insurer sets your share after its investigation, the GAA notes.

Compare before you decide

One request, up to three quotes from licensed Québec partners. Free and no obligation.

Compare my auto insurance quotes

At the scene after a parking lot accident in Québec

The Code also applies on private land

The Highway Safety Code mainly governs public highways and covers private roads and land only in the cases it specifies (section 1). The obligations in case of accident are among them: they apply to accidents occurring “on any road or land” (section 166.1), whether the parking lot is public or private. The rule on backing up also applies on land occupied by shopping centres and other land where public traffic is allowed: you may drive in reverse only if you can do so safely and without obstructing traffic (section 417).

Stay at the scene and identify yourself

The driver of a vehicle involved in an accident must remain at or immediately return to the scene and render the necessary assistance to anyone who has sustained injury or damage (section 168). The driver must give that person, or the peace officer called to the scene, their name and address, licence number, the name and address of the owner entered on the registration certificate, the certificate of insurance and the number on the registration plate (section 170). Nothing obliges the other driver to fill out a joint report, the GAA points out, but the Code requires them to provide this information.

A parked vehicle with no one in it

If you hit an unattended vehicle and its owner, or a person representing them, cannot be found at the scene or nearby, you must immediately contact the nearest police station to report the accident and give the same information (section 171).

Joint report or police

If no one is injured, there is no need to call the police for a simple fender bender, the GAA says: just fill out a joint report (constat amiable), online or on paper. It lets the drivers identify themselves and report the accident to their insurers, which use it to determine their share of fault under the Agreement. Our guide Québec's Direct Compensation Agreement, explained step by step shows how to fill it out.

Call the police in the following cases:

  • Someone is injured. The driver must call for a peace officer (section 169), and the AMF advises calling 911 immediately and staying at the scene until emergency services arrive.
  • The owner of the unattended vehicle you hit cannot be found (section 171).
  • The other driver leaves without identifying themselves, which the GAA calls a hit-and-run.
  • The other driver refuses to cooperate. The GAA advises writing down their licence plate number, taking photos and, if need be, calling the police.

The police never establish the liability of the parties, the GAA specifies: your insurer does, when the claim is settled. If the police make a report, a joint report is no longer needed, according to the AMF.

How the chart decides fault

Liability is apportioned as shown in the Driver's Fault Chart appended to the Agreement, and collisions it does not provide for are settled under the ordinary rules of law (Chart, Article 1). Here are the cases that concern a parking lot.

Case 15, for parking lots with no traffic signs

Case 15 covers a collision in a parking lot with no traffic signs. It distinguishes the “main alley,” a main thoroughfare used in such a lot, and the “side alley,” a cross lane feeding another cross lane or a main alley. Two rules follow, each putting 100% of the liability on the vehicle that had to yield:

  1. a vehicle leaving a side alley must yield to a vehicle travelling on a main alley;
  2. a vehicle leaving a parking space must yield to a vehicle travelling on an alley, side or main.

Backing up

Case 11 holds the vehicle that is backing up or making a U-turn fully responsible. When two or more vehicles are backing up, liability is apportioned equally, for example between two cars reversing out of facing spaces at the same moment. For two vehicles, the GAA specifies that each is 50% responsible: each driver is compensated for half of their damage under Chapter A of their policy, for the other half if they also have collision coverage under Chapter B, and pays 50% of their deductible.

Parked vehicles and doors

A parked vehicle that is hit bears no share of liability: 0% for it, 100% for the vehicle that hits it (case 3c). The case provides only one exception, a vehicle illegally parked at night and without lights outside cities, towns or villages, where liability is split 50-50 (case 3d). Doors fall under case 12: whoever opens a door is fully responsible, even if the motion has just been completed, unless it is proven that the door was left open to let a person get in or out, or to load or unload an item, after making sure this could be done safely.

When the versions conflict

Except as otherwise provided, the chart does not take into account the point of contact, speed, visibility or road conditions: what counts is each driver's manoeuvre (Chart, Article 2). Any admission of liability is null and void (Chart, Article 1). The insurer obtains the version of each person involved and, according to the GAA, if the versions differ and no independent witness can corroborate either one, liability is, as a general rule, shared 50-50. Hence the importance of witnesses and of photos showing where the vehicles were.

Your car hit, the other driver gone

If the driver who hit your car left without identifying themselves, the Agreement does not apply, since it requires the owners to be identified (Article 3). Report the hit-and-run to the police immediately, the AMF advises: your insurer then compensates you if your policy covers damage to your vehicle, minus the deductible. Our guide Hit-and-run in Québec or an uninsured driver, who pays for what explains what remains possible without that coverage.

The claim, the deductible and your record

Report the accident to your insurer even if you do not intend to file a claim: the AMF points out that this requirement is written into your insurance contract. Our guide Filing an auto insurance claim in Québec, from the accident to the cheque describes what comes next.

According to the GAA, a driver who is not at fault is compensated even without collision coverage and pays no deductible, a driver who is 50% responsible pays half of the deductible, and a driver who is fully responsible is compensated only with collision coverage, after paying the deductible. Our guide Understanding Your Auto Insurance Deductible in Québec covers these cases in more detail.

A paid claim is reported to the Fichier central des sinistres automobiles with your percentage of liability, 0%, 50% or 100%, and a claim on a parked car goes on the record of the person who had custody of it, the GAA explains. See our guide Your claims history file and driving record, what insurers see.

Frequently asked questions

A valet or parking lot attendant damaged my car. Who pays?

When a parking lot operator or one of its employees is driving a customer's vehicle in their care, your automobile liability insurer compensates you in full if you had no control over the vehicle and the accident did not result from its condition or the way it was secured (Article 4 of the Agreement). Your insurer keeps a right of recovery against the insurer of the person who was driving (Article 11).

Is a pedestrian hit in a parking lot compensated?

Their injuries fall under the public plan, which covers all Quebecers, whether or not they were responsible, according to the SAAQ. The Automobile Insurance Act defines an accident as “any event in which damage is caused by an automobile” (section 1), and compensation is granted regardless of who is at fault (section 5). The injured person should see a physician as quickly as possible and has a maximum of 3 years to file a compensation claim.

The other driver suggests settling it between us. Is that wise?

The AMF advises against making any financial arrangements with the other driver, otherwise you may not be compensated later. If the other driver ends up claiming from their insurer, the accident will be reported to the Fichier central des sinistres automobiles and you will be named as an involved person, the GAA warns. Reporting the accident to your insurer lets it determine your share and does not commit you to filing a claim.

The parking lot has stop signs. Does case 15 still apply?

Case 15 expressly covers a parking lot with no traffic signs. The chart also provides, in general terms, that a driver who neglects a stop sign or a yield sign is fully responsible (case 9). Your insurer determines which case applies after its investigation: photograph the signs in place.

Your checklist for the first hour

  • Stay at the scene (section 168); if someone is injured, call 911.
  • Exchange the information listed in section 170: name, address, licence, registered owner, certificate of insurance and plate.
  • Fill out the joint report, without saying it was your fault.
  • Photograph the vehicles, the licence plates, the alleys and the signs; write down witnesses' contact information.
  • Unattended vehicle, owner nowhere to be found: call the nearest police station.
  • Report the accident to your insurer, even if you are not filing a claim.

We are neither an insurer nor a broker: we explain what the Agreement and the Highway Safety Code provide, and our licensed partner presents quotes to you.

Compare before you decide

One request, up to three quotes from licensed Québec partners. Free and no obligation.

Compare my auto insurance quotes

Sources

Pages consulted on November 15, 2026.

← Back to home

Get my quotes